Senator CARR (Victoria—Minister for Innovation, Industry, Science and Research) (14:58): It is extraordinary for the opposition to maintain this line of questioning when we have as the Leader of the Opposition a person who advocates the view that you have to get something from him in writing before you can actually believe it will be undertaken. We have said that the transfer arrangements between Australia and Malaysia are part of a bilateral arrangement between Australia and Malaysia, which are of course the signatories. We are seeking the assistance of the UNHCR and the UNHCR has been consulted every step of the way. The UNHCR has made it very clear on numerous occasions that it believes this arrangement is very much superior to those arrangements that were entered into when the coalition was in office. We have indicated that the UNHCR has taken the view that over time we would actually deliver a significant improvement in the protection standards— (Time expired)