Senator CARR (Victoria—Minister for Manufacturing and Minister for Defence Materiel) (14:29): The senator talks about real risks—real risks to Australian manufacturing. The real risk to Australian manufacturing is a policy position that says you can do nothing; you can pretend these problems are going to go away. The real risk is from those opposite, who take the view that somehow or other there are hero entrepreneurs out there who are going to fix up these problems by themselves without any help from the government and without any help from the rest of society. There are, of course, those opposite who take the view that we do not need to change. Of course, the reality is somewhat different. The harsh economic reality is that this country is under enormous pressure as a result of international circumstances; we need to respond to that. We need to respond to the changes that are occurring within terms of our environment and we need to change the circumstances as a result of the international economy, and that is what we are doing on this side. What are you doing?