Senator BIRMINGHAM (South Australia) (14:29): Mr President, I have a further supplementary question. Will the minister at least tell the Senate whether most of Australia's manufacturing businesses will receive any assistance under this $1.2 billion fund? Isn't it really the case that most of Australia's manufacturing businesses will miss out altogether? Why is it that the minister will not acknowledge that the carbon tax imposes significant additional cost on manufacturing businesses, is a direct threat to the competitiveness of manufacturing businesses and therefore poses a real risk of yet more job losses in manufacturing in Australia?