Mr SHORTEN (Maribyrnong—Leader of the Opposition) (14:00): My question is to the Prime Minister. Today the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare has found that health expenditure in 2012-13 grew at its lowest rate in 30 years. Further, today the AMA president said that this 'makes a mockery of the government's claims that health care spending is out of control'. Government members interjecting— The SPEAKER: There will be quiet on my right! Mr SHORTEN: Does the Prime Minister— Mr Dutton: That's because you were in government, you goose. The SPEAKER: The Minister for Health will desist! Government members interjecting— The SPEAKER: There will be silence. The Leader of the Opposition has the call. Mr SHORTEN: I will start again. My question is to the Prime Minister. Today the Institute of Health and Welfare has found that health expenditure in 2012-13 grew at its lowest rate in 30 years. Further, today the AMA president has said that this research 'makes a mockery of the government's claims that healthcare spending is out of control'. Does the Prime Minister agree with the AMA and will he now dump his unfair and unnecessary GP tax?