Mr ALBANESE (Grayndler—Prime Minister) (14:08): In 2025 there have indeed been three interest rate cuts and that has provided real relief for people. Of course, two of those were after the budget that was handed down on 25 March. We know that those opposite have spoken about the culture of dependency when it comes to providing assistance for Australians. So, in the coalition's opinion, if you are an Australian who is getting cost-of-living help, we know you are opposed to that. For those working in the public sector, well, we know that you are opposed to them continuing to work in the public sector. Or if you're working in essential services, you are an economic burden and you are bad for our national character. They think that Australians' wages, Australians' jobs and support for Australians deserves to be cut. That's really what they're saying in their subliminal—or not so subliminal—message when they speak about the 'culture of dependency'. Remember when Joe Hockey was here? He had similar language when he came to office about the 'lifters and leaners'. Those opposite think everyone but them is a leaner. They think that; we don't think that. But who are the Australians they're attacking? It's pensioners and people caring for a relative or young kids. It's people getting study allowance at uni or rent assistance. It's the nurses, teachers, doctors, public servants all getting support. The ADF personnel— Honourable members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! The Deputy Leader of the Opposition is entitled to raise his point of order in silence, and I want to hear it. Mr Ted O'Brien: It goes to relevance. The question referenced the Treasurer's spending spree and the RBA not providing relief as a result. It invited the Prime Minister to address that issue, not to try to make things up about the coalition. The SPEAKER: The Prime Minister did address that at the beginning of the question, and he is talking about spending. He's obviously not agreeing with the context of the question, so he's providing information about why he disagrees with it and giving some contrast. So he is being directly relevant. The beginning part of the question—he tackled the nub of it straightaway. If he hadn't done that—we're going to make sure he's being directly relevant. He has been. He won't be able to talk about the opposition; he hasn't been doing that for the entirety of the answer. But he's in order now. Mr ALBANESE: When you're talking about spending, which is what the question went to, and the coalition say that there's too much spending, they've got to say what it is that they'll cut—what it is that is wasteful. The Leader of the Opposition actually said what she thinks is wasteful when she spoke about the 'culture of dependency'. So, for all those people, your wages are welfare and your job is a cop-out, according to those opposite. We've heard it all before. They wanted to sack 46,000 public servants at the last election. They wanted people to stop working from home. We on this side want people to earn more, and we want people to keep more of what they earn.