Senator CORMANN (Western Australia—Minister for Finance, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:14): Ms Liu was validly elected as the member for Chisholm, and the Prime Minister has full confidence in her. This question that the Labor Party is asking here should actually be ruled out of order because, quite frankly, this is just part of Labor Party trickery. As I said last week, you're still going through your seven stages of grief. You still haven't accepted that you lost the last election. You still haven't accepted that you lost the seat of Chisholm, and you thought you already had it in your bag. You are accusing Ms Liu of being part of organisations that your Labor candidate was a member of. On the weekend we had this amazing attempt at a diversion by the Leader of the Opposition, who said, 'Oh, that shouldn't really matter, because the Labor candidate was Taiwanese.' We are not actually accusing anyone of having done anything wrong by being part of these organisations. We think it's normal that Australians of Chinese origin are involved in Chinese community organisations. It's only the Labor Party that is trying to run a smear. Whatever way you want to put it, the imputation is that you are trying to get the message to the Australian people that the Labor Party thinks that Ms Liu is a spy. That is the accusation that you are running. Senator Wong interjecting— Senator CORMANN: You're not saying it. You're not using the words, but that is what you're trying to spread. The PRESIDENT: Senator Keneally, a supplementary question?