Senator CORMANN (Western Australia—Minister for Finance and Deputy Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:20): Senator Whish-Wilson is mixing a whole series of different concepts. Royalty payments are not tax payments. That is probably why he directed the question to the wrong minister. In order to continue to the spirit of cooperation and constructive assistance I will take that question on notice and I will ensure that Senator Whish-Wilson gets an appropriate answer from the accurate minister.
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Goodenough, Ian, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Laming, Andrew, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Bandt, Adam, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Burke, Tony, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Littleproud, David, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Ellis, Kate, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Kelly, Craig, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Andrews, Kevin, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Dreyfus, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wilson, Rick, MP Ciobo, Steven, MP Dreyfus, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wallace, Andrew, MP Fletcher, Paul, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP McVeigh, John, MP Tehan, Dan, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP O'Dwyer, Kelly, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Chalmers, Jim, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Buchholz, Scott, MP Chester, Darren, MP Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George Brandis, Sen George Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George