Senator WHISH-WILSON (Tasmania) (14:19): The ANAO audit report identified that the Commonwealth does not carry out any testing of the flow meters that are used to calculate the volume of oil and gas extracted which the royalties are based on. The ANAO report found that one meter, for example, was out of action for a whole five years without anybody noticing. Given the failure of the department over the decades to audit whether the tax deductions were legitimate or not and given that we do not even know if the oil and gas meters are functioning properly, does the Australian government still have confidence in the Department of Industry, Innovation and Science to administer the Commonwealth royalty regime? (Time expired)
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Goodenough, Ian, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Laming, Andrew, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Bandt, Adam, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Burke, Tony, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Littleproud, David, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Ellis, Kate, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Kelly, Craig, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Andrews, Kevin, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Dreyfus, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wilson, Rick, MP Ciobo, Steven, MP Dreyfus, Mark, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wallace, Andrew, MP Fletcher, Paul, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP McVeigh, John, MP Tehan, Dan, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP O'Dwyer, Kelly, MP O'Dowd, Ken, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Chalmers, Jim, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Buchholz, Scott, MP Chester, Darren, MP Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Gallagher, Sen Katy Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Macdonald, Sen Ian Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Sterle, Sen Glenn Brandis, Sen George Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Cormann, Sen Mathias Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Cormann, Sen Mathias Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Williams, Sen John Sinodinos, Sen Arthur McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Ryan, Sen Scott O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew O'Sullivan, Sen Barry Canavan, Sen Matthew Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Hinch, Sen Derryn Nash, Sen Fiona Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Paterson, Sen James Birmingham, Sen Simon Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Dodson, Sen Patrick Brandis, Sen George Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Hume, Sen Jane Fifield, Sen Mitch Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George Brandis, Sen George Watt, Sen Murray Brandis, Sen George