Ms JULIE BISHOP ( Curtin — Deputy Leader of the Opposition ) ( 14:38 ): My question is to the Treasurer. I refer the Treasurer to this statement about the carbon tax by the head of the Australian Workers Union, Paul Howes. He said: … we will end up reliant on imported steel, which will not only increase our carbon footprint but will transfer offshore our jobs, our wealth … Does the Treasurer agree with Mr Howes's assessment of the effects of the carbon tax and will he agree to the AWU's demand to exempt the steel industry?