Mr HOCKEY (North Sydney) (14:03): Madam Speaker, I ask a supplementary question. I note how proud the Treasurer is of his scheme. He referred to the price of carbon in China which today is around $5 a tonne. How does the Treasurer reconcile that with the fact that in just two weeks the Australian carbon price is going to be $24.15 a tonne? How does that help Australian industry? (Time expired)