Senator ABETZ (Tasmania—Leader of the Government in the Senate, Minister Assisting the Prime Minister for the Public Service and Minister for Employment) (14:06): That question comes from the former minister and her party that promised the Australian people that there would be no carbon tax; from a government that promised that they would turn back the boats and then never did! Senator Wong, who promised a budget deficit of $18 billion and then let it blow out to $48 billion, hardly has any credibility in this space. Senator Wong: He is a liar. The PRESIDENT: Senator Wong, you will have to withdraw that. Senator Wong: I withdraw. Senator ABETZ: That is the first decent thing the Leader of the Opposition in the Senate has said this question time, and I congratulate her for it. We as a government are determined to do the right thing by the Australian people. And when Labor goes to the election promising $5 billion worth of cuts to help the budget situation, and we then put that before the Australian people and Labor votes against it— (Time expired)