Senator JOHNSTON (Western Australia—Minister for Defence) (14:34): With the greatest respect to the senator, this is a complete waste of the Senate's time. I was not there. I have not had the benefit of a minute-by-minute commentary on what took place, and where, with respect to any of these matters. I would have thought, with this particular capability, you would have had a better question.
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Sukkar, Michael, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Henderson, Sarah, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Nikolic, Andrew, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Abbott, Tony, MP McGowan, Cathy, MP Briggs, Jamie, MP Howarth, Luke, MP Keenan, Michael, MP Feeney, David, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Scott, Fiona, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Pitt, Keith, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Prentice, Jane, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Rishworth, Amanda, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Hutchinson, Eric, MP Andrews, Kevin, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Ramsey, Rowan, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Clare, Jason, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Andrews, Karen, MP Macfarlane, Ian, MP Neumann, Shayne, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Wood, Jason, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Conroy, Sen Stephen Ronaldson, Sen Michael Conroy, Sen Stephen Ronaldson, Sen Michael Conroy, Sen Stephen Ronaldson, Sen Michael Macdonald, Sen Ian Abetz, Sen Eric Macdonald, Sen Ian Abetz, Sen Eric Macdonald, Sen Ian Abetz, Sen Eric Polley, Sen Helen Fifield, Sen Mitch Polley, Sen Helen Fifield, Sen Mitch Polley, Sen Helen Fifield, Sen Mitch Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Conroy, Sen Stephen Johnston, Sen David Conroy, Sen Stephen Conroy, Sen Stephen Johnston, Sen David Muir, Sen Ricky Abetz, Sen Eric Muir, Sen Ricky Abetz, Sen Eric Muir, Sen Ricky Abetz, Sen Eric Seselja, Sen Zed Payne, Sen Marise Seselja, Sen Zed Payne, Sen Marise Seselja, Sen Zed Payne, Sen Marise Rhiannon, Sen Lee Brandis, Sen George Rhiannon, Sen Lee Brandis, Sen George Rhiannon, Sen Lee Brandis, Sen George Bullock, Sen Joesph Abetz, Sen Eric Bullock, Sen Joesph Abetz, Sen Eric Bullock, Sen Joesph Abetz, Sen Eric