Senator CORMANN (Western Australia) (14:24): Mr President, I ask a further supplementary question. Given that since the election this minister has co-presided over a $33.3 billion blow-out in the budget deficit, just last financial year, and with spending as a share of GDP higher this financial year and every year of the forward estimates than the last year of the Howard government, even before taking $120 billion of unfunded spending promises into account, why should the Australian people trust this government, notorious for breaking commitments, to deliver a budget surplus in 2012-13?
In this debate Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Brodtmann, Gai, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Swan, Wayne, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Thomson, Craig, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Hall, Jill, MP Roxon, Nicola, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Rishworth, Amanda, MP Burke, Tony, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Perrett, Graham, MP Emerson, Craig, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Cheeseman, Darren, MP Combet, Greg, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Livermore, Kirsten, MP Crean, Simon, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Cash, Sen Michaelia Lundy, Sen Kate Cash, Sen Michaelia Lundy, Sen Kate Cash, Sen Michaelia Lundy, Sen Kate Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Bishop, Sen Mark Wong, Sen Penny Bishop, Sen Mark Wong, Sen Penny Bishop, Sen Mark Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Wong, Sen Penny Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Conroy, Sen Stephen Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Conroy, Sen Stephen Whish-Wilson, Sen Peter Conroy, Sen Stephen Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen McKenzie, Sen Bridget Conroy, Sen Stephen Conroy, Sen Stephen McKenzie, Sen Bridget Conroy, Sen Stephen McKenzie, Sen Bridget Conroy, Sen Stephen Moore, Sen Claire Carr, Sen Bob Moore, Sen Claire Carr, Sen Bob Moore, Sen Claire Carr, Sen Bob Birmingham, Sen Simon Conroy, Sen Stephen Birmingham, Sen Simon Conroy, Sen Stephen Birmingham, Sen Simon Conroy, Sen Stephen Gallacher, Sen Alex Lundy, Sen Kate Gallacher, Sen Alex Lundy, Sen Kate Gallacher, Sen Alex Lundy, Sen Kate Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Wong, Sen Penny Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Wong, Sen Penny Sinodinos, Sen Arthur Wong, Sen Penny