Senator CORMANN (Western Australia) (14:29): My question is to the Minister for Finance and Deregulation, Senator Wong. I refer the minister to the government's budget papers which said (1) there is no provision in the budget for the carbon tax, (2) that the carbon tax will be budget neutral and (3) that the budget contingency reserve is not a general policy reserve. Given that the government is now raiding the contingency reserve because of its carbon tax, for which the funds will need to be appropriated in order to support power plant compensation, is this not a Whitlamesque move which breaks each one of these three commitments made just two months ago?
In this debate Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Sidebottom, Sid, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Irons, Steve, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Ferguson, Martin, MP Buchholz, Scott, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Windsor, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Ripoll, Bernie, MP O'Connor, Brendan, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Melham, Daryl, MP Roxon, Nicola, MP Marino, Nola, MP Swan, Wayne, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Combet, Greg, MP Robb, Andrew, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Owens, Julie, MP Garrett, Peter, MP Roy, Wyatt, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Lyons, Geoff, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Baldwin, Bob, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Gibbons, Steve, MP Butler, Mark, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Sidebottom, Sid, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Irons, Steve, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Fitzgibbon, Joel, MP Ferguson, Martin, MP Buchholz, Scott, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Windsor, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Ripoll, Bernie, MP O'Connor, Brendan, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Melham, Daryl, MP Roxon, Nicola, MP Marino, Nola, MP Swan, Wayne, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Combet, Greg, MP Robb, Andrew, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Owens, Julie, MP Garrett, Peter, MP Roy, Wyatt, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Lyons, Geoff, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Baldwin, Bob, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Gibbons, Steve, MP Butler, Mark, MP Fisher, Sen Mary Jo Ludwig, Sen Joe Fisher, Sen Mary Jo Ludwig, Sen Joe Fisher, Sen Mary Jo Ludwig, Sen Joe Urquhart, Sen Anne Arbib, Sen Mark Urquhart, Sen Anne Arbib, Sen Mark Urquhart, Sen Anne Arbib, Sen Mark Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Brandis, Sen George Wong, Sen Penny Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Thistlethwaite, Sen Matt Sherry, Sen Nick Thistlethwaite, Sen Matt Sherry, Sen Nick Thistlethwaite, Sen Matt Sherry, Sen Nick Fifield, Sen Mitch Wong, Sen Penny Fifield, Sen Mitch Wong, Sen Penny Fifield, Sen Mitch Wong, Sen Penny Hogg, Sen John Xenophon, Sen Nick Evans, Sen Christopher Xenophon, Sen Nick Evans, Sen Christopher Xenophon, Sen Nick Evans, Sen Christopher Birmingham, Sen Simon Wong, Sen Penny Birmingham, Sen Simon Wong, Sen Penny Birmingham, Sen Simon Wong, Sen Penny