Mr TURNBULL (Wentworth—Prime Minister) (14:26): I want to thank the honourable member for raising the subject of penalty rates, because he is sitting with a group of Olympic-class champions at getting rid of penalty rates—trading them away one after the other. How many students working on weekends at McDonald's don't get any penalty rates at all because of the agreement entered into by their union? Ms Ryan interjecting— Mr TURNBULL: Oh, yes—not a cut: they get nothing. The Labor Party has failed those workers. And do you know what, Mr Speaker— Mr Perrett: Can't spell anything— The SPEAKER: Okay. Well, you've just jumped the queue. The member for Moreton can leave under 94(a). And the member for Lalor, who has been warned, can leave under 94(a) as well. The member for Moreton and the member for Lalor then left the chamber. Mr TURNBULL: Under our Personal Income Tax Plan, people in the higher tax bracket of $200,000-plus will pay a larger share of the total income tax collection than they do today. So if that's the definition of 'progressive', it is much more progressive than it is today. So the Labor Party has no basis for complaining about the equity of the tax plan. But this is the big difference: just like the member for Sydney, the member for Rankin does not want that person working on a low or lower-middle income to get ahead. He does not want them to get ahead— Dr Chalmers: We want to give them a bigger tax cut! The SPEAKER: The member for Rankin is now warned. Mr TURNBULL: The idea that someone on $40,000, or $50,000, or $60,000 or $70,000 may aspire to earn more is lost on the privileged elite of the Labor Party opposite. Opposition members interjecting— Mr TURNBULL: Oh, yes! Those seats used to be filled by men and women who had worked with their hands, who had done those low-income jobs, and now we get one university-educated apparatchik after another, who has got in there and is failing the very workers their forebears used to represent. No wonder Paul Keating is disgusted by the failure of the modern Labor Party to connect to Australians' aspirations! We know Australians want to get ahead. We know they are encouraged by the stronger economy to get ahead, and we will constantly remind them that the greatest threat to that stronger economy is the modern Labor Party, with its denial of aspiration—the denials of self-advancement that workers for generations used to deliver through the efforts of Labor representatives. This Labor Party is a disgrace to all the Labor history and Labor leaders of the past.