Senator SHOEBRIDGE (New South Wales) (14:19): Given you have repeatedly stated that the Australian government has full knowledge of and concurrence with what happens at Pine Gap, what steps have you taken to ensure the joint US-Australian spy facility at Pine Gap is not being used to assist the Israeli military in its breaches of international law as identified? Senator Watt: A point of order, President: I don't really see how that's relevant to the primary question that Senator Shoebridge asked. The PRESIDENT: I'll seek some advice on that. I am advised that the question is quite comprehensive in the way it has been drafted; therefore, it drifts across some portfolio areas. As a supplementary question, it does also contain some references to the primary question, so I'm going to invite the minister to answer the question which relates specifically to her portfolio matters.