Senator McALLISTER (New South Wales—Minister for Emergency Management and Minister for Cities) (14:10): Senator Ciccone is right to remember that, in 2022, the Coalition voted against energy bill relief for pensioners, low-income families, veterans and some of our most vulnerable households. They opposed our plan. Senator Colbeck interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Colbeck, it is not like you to be so vocal, but I have called you a lot this week. I'm asking you to listen in silence. Senator McALLISTER: Senators will also recall that those opposite opposed our plan to cap coal and gas prices. Wholesale electricity prices are currently around $48, and that is less than one-fifth of the $286 they were when the coalition left office. One of the most important interventions that our government is making is actually restoring certainty and policy predictability to the energy market after a decade of division and disunity. Recently we've seen more evidence of disunity, with Senator Canavan saying net zero is dead, and the member for Hinkler calling for the coalition to reconsider policies around net zero. It is back to the future with this one. (Time expired) The PRESIDENT: Senator Ciccone, second supplementary?