Senator CORMANN (Western Australia—Minister for Finance) (14:25): As I have indicated in my previous answers, we are taking effective action on climate change—unlike the Labor-Greens carbon tax which was not only going to hit families, not only going to hit pensioners, not only going to hit small business and bigger businesses but to do so without doing anything to help reduce emissions in Australia. We are taking action that is actually making a difference to the environment in a way that is economically responsible. We can go round and round in circles on this. I would actually be concerned if Senator Milne was supportive of our approach to the economy and the environment because it just would not be responsible for us to agree with Senator Milne and the Greens about the best way forward when it comes to economic growth— The PRESIDENT: Pause the clock. Senator Rice, on a point of order. Senator Rice: Mr President, I rise on a point of order: relevance. The question was about where the economic modelling of the impacts of climate change on various sectors of our economy is. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Rice. Again, I remind the minister of the question. You have 18 seconds in which to answer. Senator CORMANN: The government has conducted all of the relevant and appropriate economic modelling for the purposes of this exercise. We stand by that. Of course, what this report shows is the need to continue to implement our plan for a stronger, more prosperous economy and more jobs. (Time expired)