Senator ABETZ (Tasmania—Leader of the Government in the Senate, Minister Assisting the Prime Minister for the Public Service and Minister for Employment) (14:04): No, I will not do that. I think it is the absolute height of hypocrisy of the Australian Labor Party that went to two elections—one in 2010 saying that there would be no carbon tax, then to the 2013 election saying that they had already abolished the carbon tax. Then when we brought in the abolition of the carbon tax legislation they voted against it. Senator Wong: I rise on a point of order. The point of order is in relation to direct relevance. The minister was asked about his election promise and the Prime Minister's election promise. I invite him to repeat the Prime Minister's or the minister's election promise, about which he was asked, that the submarines would be built in Adelaide. Why don't you put it on the record today? The PRESIDENT: Senator Wong, you have made your point. There is no point of order. Your question started, 'Can the minister confirm,' and the opening lines of the minister's answer was, 'No, I cannot.' The minister is being directly relevant. Senator ABETZ: Having answered the question straight off the bat, I am now outlining to the failed former finance minister of the record of her government with broken promises. As a former failed finance minister she might like to recall the promises that were made to the Australian people, day after day, about the surplus that they would deliver, and which never was delivered. That is why we have some situations to clean up— (Time expired)