Senator FIFIELD (Victoria—Manager of Opposition Business in the Senate) (14:05): Mr President, I ask a further supplementary question. I note that the minister has not at any stage stated that there will be direct compensation to disability and not-for-profit groups. How can the minister claim that this carbon tax plan is fair when we know it will leave millions of small businesses, millions of households and millions of families worse off and, as highlighted by ACOSS, will even leave disability, volunteer and charitable service providers serving the most vulnerable worse off?
In this debate Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Symon, Mike, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Schultz, Alby, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Windsor, Tony, MP Combet, Greg, MP Rishworth, Amanda, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bird, Sharon, MP Combet, Greg, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Symon, Mike, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Schultz, Alby, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Windsor, Tony, MP Combet, Greg, MP Rishworth, Amanda, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bird, Sharon, MP Combet, Greg, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Fifield, Sen Mitch Wong, Sen Penny Fifield, Sen Mitch Wong, Sen Penny Wong, Sen Penny Pratt, Sen Louise Evans, Sen Christopher Pratt, Sen Louise Evans, Sen Christopher Pratt, Sen Louise Evans, Sen Christopher Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Siewert, Sen Rachel Ludwig, Sen Joe Siewert, Sen Rachel Ludwig, Sen Joe Siewert, Sen Rachel Ludwig, Sen Joe Johnston, Sen David Evans, Sen Christopher Johnston, Sen David Evans, Sen Christopher Johnston, Sen David Evans, Sen Christopher Gallacher, Sen Alex Ludwig, Sen Joe Gallacher, Sen Alex Ludwig, Sen Joe Gallacher, Sen Alex Ludwig, Sen Joe McKenzie, Sen Bridget Wong, Sen Penny McKenzie, Sen Bridget Wong, Sen Penny McKenzie, Sen Bridget Wong, Sen Penny Xenophon, Sen Nick Sherry, Sen Nick Xenophon, Sen Nick Sherry, Sen Nick Xenophon, Sen Nick Sherry, Sen Nick Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Brown, Sen Carol Carr, Sen Kim Brown, Sen Carol Carr, Sen Kim