Ms LEY (Farrer—Deputy Leader of the Opposition) (14:39): My question is to the Prime Minister. Some families are paying up to a thousand dollars more for their electricity since Labor was elected two years ago. After three failed budgets, the energy rebate announced on Tuesday is finally an admission that the government broke its promise to cut energy bills. The only thing made in Australia is this inflation crisis. Why are Australian families paying the price for the Prime Minister's weak economic leadership? Dr Chalmers interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! The Treasurer will cease interjecting. The Deputy Leader of the Opposition has asked her question. She was heard in silence. The Prime Minister hasn't begun his answer yet. I'm sure he may get a response, but wait to see what is said first.