Ms GILLARD (Lalor—Prime Minister) (14:50): I have dealt with those claims previously. I have dealt with them in here and I have dealt with them outside the parliament. The Deputy Leader of the Opposition is at the bottom of the mud bucket now and she does not actually have any new mud left. The problem for the Deputy Leader of the Opposition is that she and the Leader of the Opposition came into this parliament with a strategy of smear. Together, they got the mud. They used the old Liberal Party dirt file and added to it. The SPEAKER: The Prime Minister will return to the question. Ms GILLARD: The strategy was that the Leader of the Opposition would be quiet as the Deputy Leader of the Opposition threw the mud. Here we are on day 3 and it is the Deputy Leader of the Opposition who is covered in mud, but it is time that the Leader of the Opposition took personal responsibility. (Time expired)