Senator WONG (South Australia—Minister for Finance and Deregulation) (14:06): Thank you, Mr President— Senator Cormann: Why do you need to remove the special circumstances? The PRESIDENT: Senator Cormann, you have asked your question. The minister deserves the opportunity to answer. Senator WONG: I think the only people who are talking about transparency, or a lack thereof, are members of the opposition, who failed to look at this issue in the budget papers and in the appropriation bills. They come in here and suggest that the government has not been transparent, when this is clearly articulated in the budget papers and in the appropriation bills. The question for the opposition is: if you are so concerned about debt, why are you opposing the government's savings measures? You cannot come in here and talk about debt while you are set to wreck the budget surplus.