Mr ALBANESE (Grayndler—Prime Minister) (14:57): I thank the Leader of the Opposition for his question. I note the regular tracks of members of the LNP to sit on the same side as the government at various times—something that they say is a positive. Ms O'Neil: And how many MPs have you lost this term, eh? The SPEAKER: Order. The Minister for Home Affairs will cease interjecting. Mr Pasin interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Barker is warned. The Prime Minister is going to be heard in silence. Mr ALBANESE: I make this point: 'from the river to the sea' refers to the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. The problem with 'from the river to the sea' being one state, whether just Israel or just Palestine, is that it denies the existence of the other peoples and denies the need for a two-state solution, which is why I have consistently opposed it. I have consistently supported two states—Palestine and Israel—living side by side in peace and security, and that is the Australian Labor Party's position, and I'm proud of it. I have consistently opposed the actions from day one of what occurred with the terrorist act on October 7. Hamas committed atrocities and need to be totally condemned. I have also expressed my grave concern at the humanitarian loss in Gaza, including our call for the ground invasion of Rafah to not occur. We warned of what the consequences of that would be. I regret the loss of all innocent life, whether it be Israeli or Palestinian. That is the principled position that I have taken. That is why I have—yesterday, the position that was put forward by Senator Wong in the Senate was a principled one: the need for the Senate to recognise the state of Palestine as a part of a peace process in support of a two-state solution and a just and enduring peace. It's beyond me why the Greens political party or the Liberal Party or the National Party did not support that position. For the truth is that they did not. That is the appropriate position being put forward. I met with Senator Payman earlier today. She will not be attending the Labor caucus for the rest of this session. Mr Dutton: Was that her decision or yours? The SPEAKER: Order! The Leader of the Opposition will cease interjecting. Ms Lawrence interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Hasluck. Honourable members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! Ministers will cease interjecting. Mr Dutton interjecting— The SPEAKER: The Prime Minister is addressing the question directly. The Prime Minister is directly answering the question. He is mentioning the person you mentioned in your question. It is impossible to take a question on relevance. Resume your seat. Under the standing orders that is not— Mr Dutton interjecting— The SPEAKER: I will refer to earlier decisions by Speaker Smith on exactly this issue regarding not taking points of order when the Speaker believes the Prime Minister or minister is being directly relevant. Resume your seat. The Prime Minister has the call. Government members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Members on my right! Mr ALBANESE: What I do is show leadership through our united team. What he does is fail to provide any leadership, which is why the kiss of death is endorsed from this block. (Time expired)