Mr GILES (Scullin—Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs) (15:10): I thank the Deputy Leader of the Liberal Party for her question, although perhaps it's a question she could have addressed to herself as someone who voted for the legislation. While she is answering that, she could also ask herself this question: why did she, not once but twice, vote against a bill which passed the House this week which did exactly that? What a joke.