Mr CONAGHAN (Cowper) (15:12): My question is to the Prime Minister. My constituent Robert Withers lives in Port Macquarie, in my electorate of Cowper. His recent electricity bill showed that he had reduced his usage by 10 per cent from the same period last year. However, the charges have risen by 40 per cent. The Prime Minister promised Australians, like Robert, that he would cut their power bills by $275, but Robert is now $800 out of pocket in real terms. Why do Australians always pay more under Labor? Honourable members in terjecting— The SPEAKER: I heard 'why do Australians', so I will allow— Honourable members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! We can simply move on if you want to. Everyone just remain silent. The question is in order—just. I just remind members that there are time limits. I give the call to the Prime Minister regarding the couple of sentences at the end that were short.