Senator WONG (South Australia—Minister for Foreign Affairs and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:12): I thank the senator for her question, and I would make this point. Obviously, details of the energy price relief plan, which required bilateral discussions with all states and territories, will be demonstrated in some detail in tonight's budget. It does seem strange—just like it did with the housing question—that we get a question from a coalition senator about energy price relief after they voted against it. You voted against it! You voted against the plan that you're now asking questions about. Senator Birmingham: Because you weren't going to deliver. Senator WONG: It's because our policies weren't going to deliver, he says. It's interesting, isn't it? They come in here and they say, 'We're for energy price relief—sort of—but we're going to vote against it, and actually, we've got nothing else on the table to deliver.' There's only one party here, one party of government, that is absolutely clear about the responsibility and opportunity of government to deliver price relief to Australian families. We know that energy prices have risen less than they would have if you had been government. Those opposite irresponsibly voted against price relief for Australian families and we will ensure, between now and the next election, that every time you raise energy prices we will remind everybody who is listening that you voted against it. All of you voted against it, and really, you should go out to the Australian people— Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order! Senator WONG: and you should apologise for your refusal to give some price relief to families who are struggling with higher prices. As always, those opposite are still too focused on the ideology, not on practical outcomes, and their only response to energy price increases was to try and hide them before the last election. Opposition s enators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order on my left! When you ask a question and the minister responds, I expect there to be order. I shouldn't have to call 'Order' three or four times to get order. I'm asking you to respect the Senate. Senator Hughes, a first supplementary question.