Mr SHORTEN (Maribyrnong—Leader of the Opposition) (15:02): My question is to the Prime Minister. Upon announcing his ministry on 16 September last year, the Prime Minister unequivocally said: Well, I want to absolutely scotch any suggestion that there is a cloud over Arthur Sinodinos. There is not. I wouldn’t be appointing Arthur to the incoming ministry if I thought there was any cloud over him. What has changed materially since then, or did the Prime Minister knowingly appoint Arthur Sinodinos to a key economic portfolio when in fact he believed there was a cloud? A government member: Are you judge and jury now, Bill? Opposition members interjecting— The SPEAKER: Order! There will be silence on my right as well as on my left!