Senator WATERS (Queensland—Leader of the Australian Greens) (14:22): This, perhaps, is why Chevron, BHP and the Minerals Council are loving these reforms. Can the minister rule out doing a dirty deal on these critical reforms with the chaos monkeys over here—the coal-loving, climate-denying, pro-emissions coalition? The PRESIDENT: Senator Waters, I'm going to ask you to withdraw. Please withdraw that comment. It's 'senators' in this chamber, so I'd ask you to withdraw that comment. Senator WATERS: The chaotic senators. The PRESIDENT: No, Senator Waters. You're being disrespectful to me, because I did ask you simply to withdraw. Senator WATERS: I withdraw. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Waters. Have you finished your question? Yes. Minister.
In this debate Ley, Sussan Penelope MP Albanese, Anthony MP Briskey, Jo MP Albanese, Anthony MP Violi, Aaron MP Albanese, Anthony MP French, Tom MP King, Madeleine MP Steggall, Zali MP Albanese, Anthony MP Burke, Tony MP Phillips, Fiona MP Bowen, Chris MP O'Brien, Ted MP Albanese, Anthony MP Abdo, Basem MP Butler, Mark Christopher MP Chester, Darren MP Keogh, Matt MP Stanley, Anne MP Chalmers, Jim MP McIntosh, Melissa MP Albanese, Anthony MP Chesters, Lisa MP King, Catherine Fiona MP Watson-Brown, Elizabeth MP Albanese, Anthony MP France, Ali MP Albanese, Anthony MP Pike, Henry MP Albanese, Anthony MP Cook, Trish MP Collins, Julie Maree MP Wilkie, Andrew MP Bowen, Chris MP Miller-Frost, Louise MP Giles, Andrew MP Paterson, Sen James McKenzie, Sen Bridget Gallagher, Sen Katy McKenzie, Sen Bridget Gallagher, Sen Katy McKenzie, Sen Bridget Gallagher, Sen Katy Smith, Sen Marielle Gallagher, Sen Katy Smith, Sen Marielle Gallagher, Sen Katy Smith, Sen Marielle Gallagher, Sen Katy Whitten, Sen Tyron McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Whitten, Sen Tyron McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Whitten, Sen Tyron McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Waters, Sen Larissa Watt, Sen Murray Waters, Sen Larissa Watt, Sen Murray Watt, Sen Murray Mulholland, Sen Corinne Ayres, Sen Tim Mulholland, Sen Corinne Ayres, Sen Tim Mulholland, Sen Corinne Ayres, Sen Tim Thorpe, Sen Lidia Watt, Sen Murray Thorpe, Sen Lidia Watt, Sen Murray Thorpe, Sen Lidia Watt, Sen Murray Bragg, Sen Andrew Wong, Sen Penny Bragg, Sen Andrew Wong, Sen Penny Bragg, Sen Andrew Wong, Sen Penny Roberts, Sen Malcolm Watt, Sen Murray Roberts, Sen Malcolm Watt, Sen Murray Roberts, Sen Malcolm Watt, Sen Murray Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Watt, Sen Murray Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Watt, Sen Murray Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah Watt, Sen Murray O'Sullivan, Sen Matt McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri O'Sullivan, Sen Matt McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri O'Sullivan, Sen Matt McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri McKim, Sen Nick Watt, Sen Murray McKim, Sen Nick Watt, Sen Murray McKim, Sen Nick Watt, Sen Murray McDonald, Sen Susan Wong, Sen Penny McDonald, Sen Susan Wong, Sen Penny McDonald, Sen Susan Wong, Sen Penny Askew, Sen Wendy McAllister, Sen Jenny Askew, Sen Wendy McAllister, Sen Jenny Askew, Sen Wendy McAllister, Sen Jenny Hodgins-May, Sen Steph Watt, Sen Murray Hodgins-May, Sen Steph Watt, Sen Murray Hodgins-May, Sen Steph Watt, Sen Murray Colbeck, Sen Richard Watt, Sen Murray Colbeck, Sen Richard Watt, Sen Murray Colbeck, Sen Richard Watt, Sen Murray