Senator WONG (South Australia—Minister for Foreign Affairs and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:14): I first make the point that our plan is delivering cheaper energy right now. We delivered energy relief, which has cut $300 off power bills. The person who asked that question is of a party that has voted against every piece of energy bill relief that we have provided to Australians. The PRESIDENT: Minister Wong, please resume your seat. Senator McGrath, a point of order? Senator McGrath: I regret to do this, but I have a point of order on relevance. The question was actually, 'Did the Prime Minister deliver on his promise in relation to the $275 reduction that was made 97 times?' I don't believe the minister is anywhere near answering that. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator McGrath. The minister has started her answer. You've repeated the question, so I will continue to listen carefully. Senator WONG: I said at the outset our plan is delivering cheaper energy right now, and we've delivered energy relief which has cut hundreds of dollars off Australians' power bills. We delivered $650 in energy relief to small business— The PRESIDENT: Minister Wong, please resume your seat. Senator Cash, a point of order? Senator Cash: Point of order in relation to relevance— Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: I'm sorry, Senator Cash. I'm going to call the Senate to order. Senator Cash: It's a point of order in relation to relevance. The question was: given that the Prime Minister made a promise to the Australian people, did he deliver it? The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator Cash. Minister Wong, I'll remind you of the question and invite you to continue your response. Senator WONG: President, I've answered it. Our plan is delivering cheaper energy now, and it stands in stark contrast to the nuclear fantasy, which will push up power prices by $1,200 and deliver less than four per cent of our energy needs. You don't like these facts, do you? The PRESIDENT: Minister Wong, please resume your seat. Senator McGrath, a point of order? Senator McGrath: There is a point of order on relevance that I wish to raise, and that is that the opposition's policy in relation to nuclear energy has absolutely nothing to do with the question I put to Senator Wong about the Prime Minister keeping his promises. The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath, that is a debating point. What I'm advised is that talking about the opposition's policies is not relevant, but the minister is being relevant to the question that you asked, Senator McGrath. Senator WONG: Our plan is delivering cheaper energy right now, and I welcome the fact that the opposition wants to avoid talking about their policy. Before the election, Australians are going to know precisely what your policy is, Senator McGrath. It will deliver more expensive energy, it will cost $600 billion and you would have to pay for it. People will know about that. The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath, first supplementary?