Senator BIRMINGHAM (South Australia—Leader of the Opposition in the Senate) (14:20): Indeed, in 2017 the then immigration minister, Mr Peter Dutton, did cancel Mr Abdel-Hady's visa. And yet this week, the now immigration minister, Mr Giles, has put him on a visa that lets him back out on the street without strict conditions. Does Mr Giles or the government know where Mr Abdel-Hady is now? And how long will he now be in the Australian community because of Minister Giles' decision? Opposition senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Before I call Senator Gallagher, I am going to wait for silence, particularly on my left. Minister Gallagher.