Senator WATT (Queensland—Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry and Minister for Emergency Management) (14:20): Senator Cash, I don't have the bill in front of me, but the 'closing loopholes' bill gives service contractors a clear pathway for demonstrating that their arrangements are not those that the government aims to address with this measure. I've already indicated what the intention is here, but the intention of the opposition in this debate is to keep the loopholes wide open— The PRESIDENT: Minister, please resume your seat. Senator Cash? Senator Cash: A point of order on direct relevance. I asked the Minister a simple and very clear question: what section of the bill provides the specific exclusion for service contractors? If the minister does not know, I am more than happy for him to take it on notice. The PRESIDENT: Senator Cash, you also talked about short-term contracts. I believe the minister is being relevant, but I will continue to listen, particularly to your point of order on direct relevance. Senator WATT: What this is really about is a coalition that still haven't gotten over the fact that they lost the last election. They can't get over the fact that there is a government that wants to close the loopholes. I mentioned earlier in the week that Senator Cash was saying that IR changes would take us back to the Dark Ages, but why stop there? Why not say that it's going to take us back to the Ice Age? That's right—you did that by freezing wages for 10 years. We had frozen wages in your ice age. Why not go back even further to the Jurassic age, because there are certainly a lot of dinosaurs opposite when it comes to workplace relations policy! The Dark Ages, the Ice Age, the Jurassic age—take your pick! What we know is that you are the people who want to keep those loopholes open, who want to keep workers being exploited and who want to support employers who are undercutting their competitors. Senator McGrath interjecting— The PRES IDENT: Senator McGrath, that was incredibly disorderly to continue to shout out. Senator Cash, a second supplementary question?