Senator DUNIAM (Tasmania—Deputy Manager of Opposition Business) (14:03): Let's try and come back to what I was asking about. I refer again to the minister's answer of last Thursday, where he queried, 'So are ACCI telling us they're opposed to a wage rise?' followed by a sarcastic comment where he said 'shock, horror'. Does the minister agree that it's extraordinary for a cabinet minister to so petulantly attack a key stakeholder about their concerns about job creation?