Senator HENDERSON (Victoria) (14:39): As part of the former government's consultation on the online privacy bill, Optus argued that telecommunications companies should be exempt from tougher online privacy laws. More broadly, Telstra and Optus also argued against consumers having the right to erase their personal data. Does the government agree that telecommunications companies should be exempt from tougher online privacy laws? Honourable se nators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: I'm not going to call the minister until there's quiet. Minister.