Senator WATT (Queensland—Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry and Minister for Emergency Management) (14:04): Senator McGrath, I don't know who's feeding you your questions, but you should have a read of them before you ask them. If you want to talk about lower productivity in this country, who was responsible for lower productivity over the last nine years? You. It was the opposition that was responsible for that, through a conflict driven IR system. Honourable senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Minister Watt, please resume your seat. Senator Payne: It's pretty easy to guarantee it. The PRESIDENT: Senator Payne! I would ask the Senate to listen quietly so that we can all hear the response from the minister. Senator WATT: Thank you, President. It's good to good to know Senator Payne is still here. I had not heard much from her since the election, so it is good to hear from her. We want to talk about lower productivity. Senator Payne interjecting— Senator WATT: Oh, you are back! You're back! The PRESIDENT: Order! Minister. Senator WATT: I'm welcoming more contributions from Senator Payne; that's what I'm doing. Now, seriously, lower productivity: if you want to talk about an IR system that delivers lower productivity, have a look in the mirror. You had nine years of delivering lower productivity through an IR system that was all about conflict and not about agreement. That's what we're trying to fix. We're trying to fix an IR system that is riven with conflict, and you want to drag us back to a system with lower productivity and lower wages That's why the Australian people voted against you, because they want more agreement and less conflict. (Time expired) The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath, a second supplementary question?