Senator BIRMINGHAM (South Australia—Minister for Finance, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:53): Mr President, I don't believe there is a case to believe as Senator Sheldon has suggested there. I will come back to the chamber if there is anything to the contrary in that regard. The PRESIDENT: Senator Sheldon, a supplementary question?
In this debate Chalmers, Jim, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Alexander, John, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Marles, Richard, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Hamilton, Garth, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Porter, Christian, MP Bandt, Adam, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Christensen, George, MP McCormack, Michael, MP Watts, Tim, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Martin, Fiona, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Burke, Tony, MP Porter, Christian, MP Bell, Angie, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Burns, Josh, MP Porter, Christian, MP Wicks, Lucy, MP Robert, Stuart, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Porter, Christian, MP Allen, Katrina, MP Andrews, Karen, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Conaghan, Patrick, MP Coulton, Mark, MP Murphy, Peta, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Young, Terry, MP Taylor, Angus, MP Claydon, Sharon, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Pearce, Gavin, MP Littleproud, David, MP Plibersek, Tanya, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Hammond, Celia, MP Price, Melissa, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Wallace, Andrew, MP Dutton, Peter, MP Gallagher, Sen Katy Birmingham, Sen Simon Gallagher, Sen Katy Birmingham, Sen Simon Gallagher, Sen Katy Birmingham, Sen Simon Chandler, Sen Claire Colbeck, Sen Richard Chandler, Sen Claire Colbeck, Sen Richard Chandler, Sen Claire Colbeck, Sen Richard Polley, Sen Helen Reynolds, Sen Linda Polley, Sen Helen Reynolds, Sen Linda Polley, Sen Helen Reynolds, Sen Linda Henderson, Sen Sarah Payne, Sen Marise Henderson, Sen Sarah Payne, Sen Marise Henderson, Sen Sarah Payne, Sen Marise Waters, Sen Larissa Birmingham, Sen Simon Waters, Sen Larissa Birmingham, Sen Simon Waters, Sen Larissa Birmingham, Sen Simon Gallacher, Sen Alex Birmingham, Sen Simon Gallacher, Sen Alex Birmingham, Sen Simon Gallacher, Sen Alex Birmingham, Sen Simon Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Hanson, Sen Pauline Birmingham, Sen Simon Hughes, Sen Hollie Cash, Sen Michaelia Hughes, Sen Hollie Cash, Sen Michaelia Hughes, Sen Hollie Cash, Sen Michaelia McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Reynolds, Sen Linda McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Reynolds, Sen Linda McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri Reynolds, Sen Linda McLachlan, Sen Andrew Seselja, Sen Zed McLachlan, Sen Andrew Seselja, Sen Zed McLachlan, Sen Andrew Seselja, Sen Zed Sheldon, Sen Anthony Sheldon, Sen Anthony Birmingham, Sen Simon Sheldon, Sen Anthony Birmingham, Sen Simon Small, Sen Benjamin Ruston, Sen Anne Small, Sen Benjamin Ruston, Sen Anne Small, Sen Benjamin Ruston, Sen Anne Pratt, Sen Louise Reynolds, Sen Linda Pratt, Sen Louise Reynolds, Sen Linda Pratt, Sen Louise Reynolds, Sen Linda