Senator KITCHING (Victoria) (13:59): My question is to Senator Brandis, the Minister representing the Prime Minister. Can the minister confirm that on various occasions Prime Minister Turnbull has supported each of the following propositions: an emissions trading scheme, a carbon tax, an emissions intensity scheme, a clean energy target and, last but not least, a stronger renewable energy target? Did Mr Turnbull believe in each of these positions as much as he does in today's?
In this debate Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Wood, Jason, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Butler, Mark, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Coleman, David, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Morrison, Scott, MP Wilkie, Andrew, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Sudmalis, Ann, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Bowen, Chris, MP Morrison, Scott, MP O'Brien, Llew, MP Joyce, Barnaby, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Marino, Nola, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Flint, Nicolle, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Butler, Mark, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Evans, Trevor, MP O'Dwyer, Kelly, MP Butler, Mark, MP Frydenberg, Josh, MP Littleproud, David, MP Ciobo, Steven, MP Burke, Tony, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Henderson, Sarah, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Brandis, Sen George Kitching, Sen Kimberley Brandis, Sen George Kitching, Sen Kimberley Brandis, Sen George Bushby, Sen David Brandis, Sen George Bushby, Sen David Brandis, Sen George Bushby, Sen David Brandis, Sen George Dastyari, Sen Sam Brandis, Sen George Dastyari, Sen Sam Brandis, Sen George Dastyari, Sen Sam Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Di Natale, Sen Richard Brandis, Sen George Gichuhi, Sen Lucy Birmingham, Sen Simon Gichuhi, Sen Lucy Birmingham, Sen Simon Gichuhi, Sen Lucy Birmingham, Sen Simon Singh, Sen Lisa Brandis, Sen George Singh, Sen Lisa Brandis, Sen George Singh, Sen Lisa Brandis, Sen George Hume, Sen Jane Cormann, Sen Mathias Hume, Sen Jane Cormann, Sen Mathias Hume, Sen Jane Cormann, Sen Mathias Hinch, Sen Derryn Birmingham, Sen Simon Hinch, Sen Derryn Birmingham, Sen Simon Hinch, Sen Derryn Cameron, Sen Doug Cash, Sen Michaelia Cameron, Sen Doug Cash, Sen Michaelia Cameron, Sen Doug Cash, Sen Michaelia Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Williams, Sen John Scullion, Sen Nigel Gallacher, Sen Alex Cash, Sen Michaelia Gallacher, Sen Alex Cash, Sen Michaelia Gallacher, Sen Alex Cash, Sen Michaelia Duniam, Sen Jonathon Birmingham, Sen Simon Duniam, Sen Jonathon Birmingham, Sen Simon Duniam, Sen Jonathon Birmingham, Sen Simon