Senator BRANDIS (Queensland—Attorney-General, Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:09): No, it is not. Obviously you have only a few pages of the presentation leaked, because— Senator Kim Carr: No, I have not. I've got the whole lot here. The PRESIDENT: Order! You have asked your question, Senator Carr. Senator BRANDIS: what the graphs you are not referring to show is that there was actually a doubling of electricity prices during the period of the Labor government—the longest sustained increase in electricity prices in the recent past. Senator Ian Macdonald: Own goal! Senator BRANDIS: Yes, Senator Macdonald, another own goal by Senator Carr from North Korea over there. I withdraw that, Mr President. The PRESIDENT: Thank you. Senator BRANDIS: So, Senator Carr, we are not going to have Soviet style economics, as you would wish us to have. We are not going to be driven by ideology, as you have been. We are going to be driven by economics and we are going to be driven by engineering. And we are going to rely upon the best advice we can, including the advice of Dr Alan Finkel, to deliver lower, affordable electricity prices; reliable supply; and commitment to international agreements. (Time expired) The PRESIDENT: A final supplementary question, Senator Carr.