Senator CORMANN (Western Australia—Minister for Finance) (14:39): Here they are, all cocky and jumping up and down. Of course we are keeping the carbon tax. Their shadow minister Mr Butler went on television to say: We do support the abolition of the carbon tax. We voted to abolish the carbon tax in the Senate … So, we're not voting to support the carbon tax. and you, here in this chamber, did the exact opposite. Of course, families across Australia could be saving $550 a year, on average—a lower cost of living—at a time when people could very much do with that help. Household average electricity bills would be around $200 lower than they otherwise would be. Honourable senators interjecting— Senator Cameron interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Cormann, resume your seat. Senator Cameron, I remind you that interjections are disorderly. Senator CORMANN: I have to say that again. The cost of living for the average family would go down by $550 a year. Their electricity costs would be $200 a year lower than they otherwise would be. Gas bills would be $70 lower a year than they otherwise would be. Of course, the Labor Party, which wants to have it both ways, is voting to keep these costs imposed on families. (Time expired)