Senator BACK (Western Australia—Deputy Opposition Whip in the Senate) (14:46): Mr President, I ask a further supplementary question. I thank the minister for the explanation that the tax group was not consulted. Minister, is it any wonder that the business and indeed the wider community now have lost total confidence in this government when, as you say, it failed to consult its own business tax reform group on such an important change in tax collection procedures while at the same time it set ground rules to ensure it was bound to fail on measures to negotiate reduced company taxes in Australia?
In this debate Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Cheeseman, Darren, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Briggs, Jamie, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Katter, Bob, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Hayes, Chris, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Hayes, Chris, MP Albanese, Anthony, MP Turnbull, Malcolm, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Rishworth, Amanda, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Champion, Nick, MP Burke, Tony, MP Pyne, Christopher, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Livermore, Kirsten, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Livermore, Kirsten, MP Shorten, Bill, MP Fletcher, Paul, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Parke, Melissa, MP Burke, Tony, MP O'Dwyer, Kelly, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Georganas, Steve, MP Combet, Greg, MP Bishop, Bronwyn, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Bilyk, Sen Catryna Evans, Sen Christopher Bilyk, Sen Catryna Evans, Sen Christopher Bilyk, Sen Catryna Evans, Sen Christopher Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Wong, Sen Penny Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Wong, Sen Penny Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta Wong, Sen Penny Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Milne, Sen Christine Ludwig, Sen Joe Joyce, Sen Barnaby Wong, Sen Penny Joyce, Sen Barnaby Wong, Sen Penny Joyce, Sen Barnaby Wong, Sen Penny Furner, Sen Mark Ludwig, Sen Joe Furner, Sen Mark Ludwig, Sen Joe Furner, Sen Mark Ludwig, Sen Joe Back, Sen Chris Wong, Sen Penny Back, Sen Chris Wong, Sen Penny Wong, Sen Penny Madigan, Sen John Ludwig, Sen Joe Madigan, Sen John Ludwig, Sen Joe Madigan, Sen John Ludwig, Sen Joe Mason, Sen Brett Evans, Sen Christopher Mason, Sen Brett Evans, Sen Christopher Mason, Sen Brett Evans, Sen Christopher Marshall, Sen Gavin Carr, Sen Kim Marshall, Sen Gavin Carr, Sen Kim Marshall, Sen Gavin Carr, Sen Kim