Senator CORMANN (Western Australia) (14:42): Mr President, I ask a further supplementary question. I ask again: given that an independent economic modeller has now revealed that the estimated revenue for the mining tax will be one-third what the government has forecast, how will the government make up the shortfall? Given yet another multibillion-dollar shortfall, how can anyone believe that Labor will deliver on its promise of a $1.5 billion surplus next financial year after a track record of $174 billion of accumulated deficits?
In this debate Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Lyons, Geoff, MP Clare, Jason, MP Truss, Warren, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP O'Neill, Deb, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abbott, Tony, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Wilkie, Andrew, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Owens, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Bishop, Julie, MP Gillard, Julia, MP D'Ath, Yvette, MP Swan, Wayne, MP Hockey, Joe, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Jones, Stephen, MP Combet, Greg, MP Jones, Stephen, MP Combet, Greg, MP Van Manen, Bert, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Murphy, John, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Murphy, John, MP Macklin, Jenny, MP Hunt, Greg, MP Gillard, Julia, MP Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Abetz, Sen Eric Evans, Sen Christopher Milne, Sen Christine Lundy, Sen Kate Milne, Sen Christine Lundy, Sen Kate Milne, Sen Christine Lundy, Sen Kate Stephens, Sen Ursula Carr, Sen Bob Stephens, Sen Ursula Carr, Sen Bob Stephens, Sen Ursula Carr, Sen Bob Ronaldson, Sen Michael Wong, Sen Penny Wong, Sen Penny Ronaldson, Sen Michael Wong, Sen Penny Ronaldson, Sen Michael Wong, Sen Penny Wright, Sen Penny Ludwig, Sen Joe Wright, Sen Penny Ludwig, Sen Joe Wright, Sen Penny Ludwig, Sen Joe Pratt, Sen Louise Carr, Sen Kim Pratt, Sen Louise Carr, Sen Kim Pratt, Sen Louise Carr, Sen Kim Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Cormann, Sen Mathias Wong, Sen Penny Wong, Sen Penny Sterle, Sen Glenn Ludwig, Sen Joe Sterle, Sen Glenn Ludwig, Sen Joe Sterle, Sen Glenn Ludwig, Sen Joe Colbeck, Sen Richard Wong, Sen Penny Colbeck, Sen Richard Wong, Sen Penny Colbeck, Sen Richard Wong, Sen Penny Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen Cameron, Sen Doug Conroy, Sen Stephen