Ms GILLARD (Lalor—Prime Minister) (14:21): It is not as a consequence of the carbon tax. Once again the Leader of the Opposition is attempting to mislead the Australian people about carbon pricing, just as he has every day, because he thinks this negativity is in his political interests. He gives not a thought to our nation or to our clean energy future; every day the only thing he is concerned about is how negative he can be today in the hope of politically profiting, and that is what motivates him to ask questions such as this one to try to mislead the Australian people. Mr Abbott: Madam Deputy Speaker, I have been accused of misleading the parliament. I seek leave to table page 107 of the government's carbon tax modelling. Leave not granted. Mr Abbott: I seek leave to table this— The DEPUTY SPEAKER ( Ms AE Burke ): The Leader of the Opposition will resume his seat. Mr Abbott: Madam Deputy Speaker, on a point of order: given that page 107 of the carbon tax modelling shows a 61.7 per cent reduction in aluminium production, I ask the Prime Minister to— The DEPUTY SPEAKER: The Leader of the Opposition will resume his seat. It is not a point of order. Mr Pyne: Madam Deputy Speaker, on a point of order: you have been very forthright about people who claim that they are misleading the parliament when others are misleading the parliament. The Prime Minister has just baldly claimed that the Leader of the Opposition has misled the parliament when in fact she is doing the misleading of the parliament, and it should not be allowed. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: There are other processes and forms of the House if the Leader of the Opposition claims he has been misrepresented. They cannot be used now, at question time, but he is fully aware of how he can use them after question time if that is what he wishes. Mr Pyne: Madam Deputy Speaker, I rise on a point of order. With the greatest of respect, I would have thought—and I hope you will take this advice from the opposition—that, if the parliament is to work, the Prime Minister cannot make misleading statements to the parliament and accuse others of making misleading statements. The DEPUTY SPEAKER: There is nothing within the standing orders that would allow me to ask the Prime Minister to withdraw. There are other forms of the House that the Leader of the Opposition is well aware of and that he can use at a later hour today.