Senator WONG (South Australia—Minister for Finance and Deregulation) (14:03): I am having a bit of a deja vu moment here. Didn't I just say in answer to the first question that I had a recollection that under FOI—because we are a more transparent government than they ever were—the senator had in fact obtained some Treasury costings? I also made the point that Dr Henry said he did not think 10-year forecasts were sensible for publication because they are too unreliable. I also made the point that, unlike those opposite, we have factored in things like— Senator Brandis: Mr President, on a point of order: the minister is being asked about her awareness of the existence of a document. In her answer to the primary question she talked about working figures. Now, in her response to the first supplementary question, she has not responded to the charge that Senator Cormann has made in his question. Either she was aware of it or she was not. If she was aware of it, she misled the public. If she was not aware of it, she was incompetent. Which is it? Senator Cormann: Mr President, to assist the minister I seek leave to table the Treasury revenue estimates of the MRRT and RSPT over 10 years— The PRESIDENT: Senator Cormann, we are on a point of order. The minister has been answering the question for 31 seconds. I draw the minister's attention to the question. There are 29 seconds remaining. Senator Cormann. Senator Cormann: Mr President, a second attempt: in order to assist the minister I seek leave to table the Treasury RSPT and MRRT revenue estimates over a period of 10 years released on 14 February 2011. The PRESIDENT: Senator Cormann, it is not a point of order. Senator Cormann: I am not raising a point of order; I am seeking leave. The PRESIDENT: Leave is not granted. Senator Chris Evans: Mr President, on a point of order: question time is a time for people to ask questions of ministers. Senator Brandis says that they are laying charges, and Senator Cormann wants to pull a stunt. I suggest to you that you only give them the call if they are prepared to ask a question in accordance with standing orders. The PRESIDENT: There is no point of order. I am going to go to the minister. The minister has 29 seconds remaining. Senator WONG: It is the case that the government does not generally publish 10-year projections for individual measures, just as Mr Costello never did for the GST. But I will take the attempted point of order from Senator Cormann because I think what he wants to table in the chamber is what Treasury has put on their website. It is hardly secret information, because it was publicly released. But what we rely on is what we published in our budget. (Time expired)