Mr BURKE (Watson—Manager of Opposition Business) (14:59): My question is to the Prime Minister. Yesterday in question time the Prime Minister claimed Labor's revenue and savings measures 'do not raise $70 billion'. Given that Parliamentary Budget Office costings have our multinational tax policy at $7 billion, tobacco excise at $47 billion, closing superannuation loopholes at $14 billion, which, together with the abolition of the Emissions Reductions Fund, raise more than $70 billion, exactly which costing was the Prime Minister disagreeing with in question time yesterday?