Mr BOWEN (McMahon) (14:28): My question is to the Treasurer. I refer to his previous answer and I also refer to the now Treasurer's statement in parliament in 2009: … so we put forward a constructive proposal to increase the excise on tobacco by 12½ per cent … So why did the Treasurer just rule out doing that by adopting Labor's plans? Mr Husic interjecting— The SPEAKER: The member for Chifley will cease interjecting.