Ms PLIBERSEK (Sydney—Deputy Leader of the Opposition) (14:11): My question is to the Prime Minister. There are 8,429 families currently receiving family tax benefit B in the seat of Capricornia. How many families with children over the age of six in Capricornia will have their payments cut as a result of this budget? Why should these families suffer because of the member for Capricornia's failure to stand up against the Prime Minister's cuts?