Senator WATT (Queensland—Minister for Employment and Workplace Relations) (14:53): By removing financial barriers, free TAFE is helping Australians to gain skills and build their future. Now, we know that Mr Dutton and the coalition have made it clear that they don't believe TAFE students are worth the investment with snobby remarks like the one from Ms Ley saying, 'If you don't pay for something, you don't value it.' Senator McGrath interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Wong. Senator Wong: I've been very Zen over a lot of interjections, but Senator McGrath has been shouting across the chamber for a great deal of question time, and I would ask him to stop. The PRESIDENT: Sadly, Senator McGrath, you have been very loud since we started question time. I invite you to make your contribution during taking note or at some other time. I ask you to come to order. Senator Ruston: On a point of order, I would like Senator Watt to withdraw his personal reflection on the Deputy Leader of the Opposition in the other place. The PRESIDENT: I will remind the chamber that that remark, which I will not go into, was being made quite freely by the opposition. I took it in the spirit that it was intended—that it was a joke—but I will ask Senator Watt to consider withdrawing. I'll put you on notice. If he withdraws it, I will not tolerate it any longer from the opposition. Senator WATT: I withdraw, President. So, at the same time, the coalition is saying that free TAFE is not worth funding. What they do think is worth funding is their secret plan for $10 billion in long lunches for bosses. The shadow Treasurer, the leading economics spokesperson in the opposition, has even claimed that their long lunches policy is a productivity measure. This week he was asked: 'And where are the productivity gains from? I guess the lunch tax deductions,' and Mr Taylor said, 'We're pulling every lever we can to drive productivity.' It's a 'parmi' productivity plan from Angus Taylor! We know that the coalition is going to cut free TAFE. They've already said they will, just like they'll cut wages. But it's rolled gold for bosses with free lunches.