Senator CANAVAN (Queensland—Deputy Leader of the Nationals in the Senate) (14:44): Minister, the Prime Minister has broken his promise to reduce power bills by $275 a year. He's broken his promise on methane emissions from cattle. And now he is breaking his promise to fund infrastructure. Why is the Prime Minister so gutless that he could not be upfront with the Australian people about his plans before they voted for him? The PRESIDENT: Senator Canavan, I ask you to withdraw that comment. Senator CANAVAN: What? How is that unparliamentary? The PRESIDENT: You made a slur against the Prime Minister. I asked— Senator Canavan interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Canavan, it's not a debating point. Senator CANAVAN: Can I ask you to reflect on that ruling, Madam President, because I have heard much worse in this chamber. I did not reflect on the Prime Minister's— The PRESIDENT: Senator Canavan, I've asked you to withdraw; I expect you to withdraw. Senator CANAVAN: I will withdraw and reword the question. Can I have that opportunity, and could I ask that you do reflect on that decision? The PRESIDENT: I'm happy to reflect. Senator CAN AVAN: Thank you very much. The PRESIDENT: Thank you for withdrawing. Senator CANAVAN: It seems a little inconsistent. So have I got a full clock? The PRESIDENT: Senator Canavan, resume your seat for a moment, please. An honourable senator interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Order! I ask all senators in this place to be respectful. Senator Canavan, I will give you the opportunity to rephrase that question. I'm happy to reset the clock, but I would ask you, when I give my directions, to stop responding. You're not in a debate with me. Please continue. Senator CANAVAN: The Prime Minister has broken his promise to reduce power bills by $275 a year. He's broken his promise on methane emissions from cattle, and now he is breaking his promise to fund infrastructure. Why has the Prime Minister not had the courage to be upfront with the Australian people about his plans before they voted for him?