Senator FARRELL (South Australia—Minister for Trade and Tourism, Special Minister of State and Deputy Leader of the Government in the Senate) (14:42): I thank Senator McGrath for his question. He obviously didn't listen to my last answer. Had he done so, he would have understood that the problems of the wine industry, the problems that you're talking about that face the wine industry right at this very moment, are directly related to the neglect and the failure of the former government— Senator McGrath interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Resume your seat, Minister. Senator McGrath, when you stand, wait for the call. Do not just announce a point of order. Opposition senators interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath stood up and said 'point of order' before he was called. Senator McGrath? Senator McGrath: Point of order: the question was quite specific. It related to domestic wine tourism in relation to a grants program. The minister is nowhere near within order. He has wandered off into the sunset talking about other things. The PRESIDENT: Thank you, Senator McGrath, we don't need the commentary. I invite the minister to either answer the question directly or take it on notice, and I ask everyone in the chamber to be quiet so we can hear the answer. Senator FARRELL: Thank you. Senator McGrath: Have you forgotten what you were saying? Senator FARRELL: No, I haven't forgotten; I know exactly what I'm going to say. Coming from Queensland, I appreciate you don't know as much about the wine industry as— Senator McGrath interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath! You just got to your feet before you were called and called out 'point of order'. You stand, you wait for the call and then you indicate it's a point of order, not as you are rising to your feet. Senator McGrath: I apologise for misusing points of order. I have a point of order. The PRESIDENT: Yes, Senator McGrath? Senator McGrath: The minister has unfairly impugned my reputation by saying I know nothing about the great wine industry of— The PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath, that is not a point of order. Resume your seat. Minister, you've got 22 seconds. Senator FARRELL: Thank you for that point of order. I'm not in any way impugning the Queensland wine industry; I'm impugning Senator McGrath! I find it difficult— The PRESIDENT: Senator Farrell, please withdraw that comment. Senator FARRELL: I will of course withdraw that. The PRESIDENT: Thank you. You have six seconds left. Senator FARRELL: I'm not sure how it is possible— Senator Ruston interjecting— Senator Wong interjecting— The PRESIDENT: Senator Ruston and Senator Wong. Senator FARRELL: to— (Time expired)