Senator HUGHES (New South Wales) (14:30): Whilst I appreciate the minister—the 'not my job' minister—Senator Watt, has taken on notice the getting of the figures, some of us have actually had a look at these papers. Perhaps you might like to explain why, under Labor's much-vaunted cost-of-living support, it's proposing to give more than five times in assistance to a family earning over $400,000 than it does to a family earning $60,000. (Time expired)